Cheap Tart Bakery makes outstanding pies and tarts for delivery within Chicago.
We make everything from scratch, by hand, using the best organic produce and dairy.
It's food you can feel good about. But mostly, it's just darn good.

Shop

Cranberry buttermilk chess pie $28.00

Cranberry buttermilk chess pie

Cranberry buttermilk chess pie

  A tangy buttermilk custard dotted with cranberries and scented with tangerine zest and freshly grated nutmeg. Serve at room temperature or warmed slightly for a perfect dessert or breakfast treat!
Price: $28.00

Cranberry buttermilk chess pie

$28.00

  Price: $28.00 Quantity:  A tangy buttermilk custard dotted with cranberries and scented with tangerine zest and freshly grated nutmeg. Serve at room temperature or warmed slightly for a perfect dessert or breakfast treat!

PieBox Christmas Package $50.00

PieBox Christmas Package

PieBox Christmas Package

This Christmas, Cheap Tart Bakery and PieBox are teaming up to offer the perfect Christmas gift for anyone on your list. Choose a cranberry buttermilk chess, decadent chocolate bourbon pecan pie, or classic apple pie and we’ll pack it snugly in a beautiful raw pine PieBox, tie it with a bow, and deliver it by […]
Includes Pie and PieBox

PieBox Christmas Package

$50.00

This Christmas, Cheap Tart Bakery and PieBox are teaming up to offer the perfect Christmas gift for anyone on your list. Choose a cranberry buttermilk chess, decadent chocolate bourbon pecan pie, or classic apple pie and we’ll pack it snugly in a beautiful raw pine PieBox, tie it with a bow, and deliver it by hand. About PieBox PieBox™ is a reusable raw pine box designed to safely...

Banoffee Pie $28.00

Banoffee Pie

Banoffee Pie

Imagine a banana cream pie, but caramelized. We fill a crispy, flaky crust with our homemade banana toffee, slices of sweet ripe banana, dark chocolate and lightly sweetened whipped cream.
Price: $28.00

Banoffee Pie

$28.00

Imagine a banana cream pie, but caramelized. We fill a crispy, flaky crust with our homemade banana toffee, slices of sweet ripe banana, dark chocolate and lightly sweetened whipped cream.

9″ Lemon Shaker Pie $28.00

9″ Lemon Shaker Pie

9″ Lemon Shaker Pie

Paper thin slices of juicy organic lemons make for a bracing sweet-tart filling. Our flakey all-butter crust is the perfect counterpoint.
Price: $28.00

9″ Lemon Shaker Pie

$28.00

Paper thin slices of juicy organic lemons make for a bracing sweet-tart filling. Our flakey all-butter crust is the perfect counterpoint.

9″ Ginger Cream Pie $28.00

9″ Ginger Cream Pie

9″ Ginger Cream Pie

A silky pastry cream spiked with both fresh and our homemade ginger syrup, and topped with a cloud of lightly sweetened whipped cream. Our crisp, all-butter crust brings it all together.
Price: $28.00

9″ Ginger Cream Pie

$28.00

A silky pastry cream spiked with both fresh and our homemade ginger syrup, and topped with a cloud of lightly sweetened whipped cream. Our crisp, all-butter crust brings it all together.

9″ Coconut Cream Pie $28.00

9″ Coconut Cream Pie

9″ Coconut Cream Pie

An aromatic pastry cream with shredded coconut fills the pastry shell. Topped with lightly sweetened whipped cream and toasted coconut in our all-butter crust.
Price: $28.00

9″ Coconut Cream Pie

$28.00

An aromatic pastry cream with shredded coconut fills the pastry shell. Topped with lightly sweetened whipped cream and toasted coconut in our all-butter crust.

Chocolate Chip Cookies $25.00

Chocolate Chip Cookies

Chocolate Chip Cookies

chewy chocolate chip cookies available for $25/dozen.
Available per dozen

Chocolate Chip Cookies

$25.00

chewy chocolate chip cookies available for $25/dozen.

9″ Roasted Root Vegetable Potpies $30.00

9″ Roasted Root Vegetable Potpies

9″ Roasted Root Vegetable Potpies

A rotating assortment of roasted fall vegetables (celeriac, yellow beets, carrots, potatoes, butternut squash, etc). in a flavorful sauce made with onions, mushrooms, herbs and a touch of cream. Baked in our flaky, herb-flecked crust. Totally vegetarian.
Price: $30.00

9″ Roasted Root Vegetable Potpies

$30.00

A rotating assortment of roasted fall vegetables (celeriac, yellow beets, carrots, potatoes, butternut squash, etc). in a flavorful sauce made with onions, mushrooms, herbs and a touch of cream. Baked in our flaky, herb-flecked crust. Totally vegetarian.

5″ Roasted Root Vegetable Potpies $8.00

5″ Roasted Root Vegetable Potpies

5″ Roasted Root Vegetable Potpies

A rotating assortment of root and other vegetables (celeriac, yellow beets, carrots, potatoes, butternut squash, etc). roasted and stirred into a flavorful sauce with onions, mushrooms, herbs and a touch of cream. Baked in our flaky, herb-flecked crust. Buy a few of the individual pies and pop ‘em in the freezer. Then reheat whenever for […]
Price: $8.00

5″ Roasted Root Vegetable Potpies

$8.00

A rotating assortment of root and other vegetables (celeriac, yellow beets, carrots, potatoes, butternut squash, etc). roasted and stirred into a flavorful sauce with onions, mushrooms, herbs and a touch of cream. Baked in our flaky, herb-flecked crust. Buy a few of the individual pies and pop ‘em in the freezer. Then reheat whenever for a satisfying meal in these chilly months. Vegetarian.

Apple Tarte Tatin $28.00

Apple Tarte Tatin

Apple Tarte Tatin

Organic apples caramelized to melt-in-your-mouth perfection on a round of our golden, all-butter pastry. A French classic—simple, chic, and irresistible.
Price: $28.00

Apple Tarte Tatin

$28.00

Organic apples caramelized to melt-in-your-mouth perfection on a round of our golden, all-butter pastry. A French classic—simple, chic, and irresistible.

9″ Maple Pecan $28.00

9″ Maple Pecan

9″ Maple Pecan

Real maple syrup, and pecans toasted to perfection.
Price: $28.00

9″ Maple Pecan

$28.00

Real maple syrup, and pecans toasted to perfection.

9″ Pumpkin Pie $28.00

9″ Pumpkin Pie

9″ Pumpkin Pie

We roast and puree real pumpkins for our pie (nothing from a can!) and add a healthy dose of warm, fall spices, just enough sweetness, and organic eggs and dairy for a delicate custard. Classic, made better.  
Price: $28.00

9″ Pumpkin Pie

$28.00

We roast and puree real pumpkins for our pie (nothing from a can!) and add a healthy dose of warm, fall spices, just enough sweetness, and organic eggs and dairy for a delicate custard. Classic, made better.  

Best Apple Pie in Chicago $28.00

Best Apple Pie in Chicago

Best Apple Pie in Chicago

First place winner of the 2011 and 2012 Bucktown Apple Pie Contest Professional Division, our apple pie is made with juicy apples, a dash of cinnamon, and our flaky all butter crust.
Price: $28.00

Best Apple Pie in Chicago

$28.00

First place winner of the 2011 and 2012 Bucktown Apple Pie Contest Professional Division, our apple pie is made with juicy apples, a dash of cinnamon, and our flaky all butter crust.

5″ Chicken Pot Pie $10.00

5″ Chicken Pot Pie

5″ Chicken Pot Pie

Free range chicken in a savory sauce with tender vegetables in our flaky herb-flecked pastry.  Serve right away or freeze for up to six months. Simply reheat in your oven for an incredible meal during these cold months!
Price: $10.00

5″ Chicken Pot Pie

$10.00

Free range chicken in a savory sauce with tender vegetables in our flaky herb-flecked pastry.  Serve right away or freeze for up to six months. Simply reheat in your oven for an incredible meal during these cold months!

Maple Pecan Pie Pops $3.00

Maple Pecan Pie Pops

Maple Pecan Pie Pops

Adorable, portable, and delicious. These are real miniature pies, not just pop tarts on sticks. Each pop measures roughly three inches across, the perfect single serving, party favor, or cocktail party dessert. Flavors are stamped on each stick so your guests can choose their favorite. For weddings and parties, ask about custom stamping! Current flavors: […]
Minimum One Dozen

Maple Pecan Pie Pops

$3.00

Adorable, portable, and delicious. These are real miniature pies, not just pop tarts on sticks. Each pop measures roughly three inches across, the perfect single serving, party favor, or cocktail party dessert. Flavors are stamped on each stick so your guests can choose their favorite. For weddings and parties, ask about custom stamping! Current flavors: Apple, Maple Pecan, and Lemon Ginger....

Classic Apple Pie Pops $3.00

Classic Apple Pie Pops

Classic Apple Pie Pops

Adorable, portable, and delicious. These are real miniature pies, not just pop tarts on sticks. Each pop measures roughly three inches across, the perfect single serving, party favor, or cocktail party dessert. Flavors are stamped on each stick so your guests can choose their favorite. For weddings and parties, ask about custom stamping! Current flavors: […]
Minimum One Dozen

Classic Apple Pie Pops

$3.00

Adorable, portable, and delicious. These are real miniature pies, not just pop tarts on sticks. Each pop measures roughly three inches across, the perfect single serving, party favor, or cocktail party dessert. Flavors are stamped on each stick so your guests can choose their favorite. For weddings and parties, ask about custom stamping! Current flavors: Apple, Maple Pecan, and Lemon Ginger....